Skip to main content

Counterargument: New York Times "Is Classical Music Dying?"

Swan Lake ballet at London's Royal Opera House...
Does Classical Music Make You Dance?
(This post is written in response to retired musician Les Dreyer's New York Times article "Is Classical Music Dying?" Dreyer opened up the conversation to the readers, posting a selection of responses, as well as a writer's response. I encourage you to review the original New York Times article.)

In this article (and subsequent writer's retort) Les Dreyer contends that classical music is dying to the likes of the "cacophony of rock and the neon glitter of “American Idol”.


While Les Dreyer does have many valid points that any classical music lover (or composer/performer like myself) can appreciate, there is a clear generational/demographic bias that scoffs at one reader's request that classical music concerts allow the audience members "rock-n-roll". 

Dreyer retorts, "What on earth does emoting with our bodies and voices have to do with classical music? Would you let out a yell of joy during a Mozart opera, or a moan of despair during “Parsifal”? 
new york times les dreyer
Classical Music In The Park (Photo credit: Photo Gallery)
While classical aficionados  would love to insist that classical music is a "high-brow" type of music in which stalwart wins out over the emotional in a concert setting, this is clearly not historically the case...not in this century nor in music of the primarily secular genre for centuries before. To bring up opera as the clear example of not being raucous ignores the very place in history the opera and much of classical music truly held. The operatic form entertained the royal snuff, but also entertained the bawdy public. In some cases, the audience was just as drunken as in any sports bar during Monday Night Football. And when classical music forms are moved onto an international stage, the delineation between the different types of concert etiquette all but disappear.

To deny that classical music has little to do with "emoting with our bodies" ignores every great ballet or dance composition ever created in the great western tradition.  

Do we really believe that ballet dancers politely stood quietly without moving their bodies in The Nutrcracker or Swan Lake? Were great Viennese waltzes simply listened to passively at great royal balls? And what of the entire library of Renaissance music, improvised and created by little more than traveling buskers looking for a good party? Perhaps only sacred classical music can fit the narrow definition presented by Les Dreyer of classical music that requires nothing but quiet thought/contemplation and little else. 

I applaud Dreyer for daring to hit such a controversial subject. As I mentioned in my unpublished response to his New York Times article, classical music is not dying. It has evolved. That audiences today see little merit in watching a concert that requires pure silence for three hours in an atmosphere prohibitive to anyone under the age of 18 (or the parent that must drag a minor to these types  of events) is not surprising. Another false premise was made here, that most people will pay high prices for pop or rock tickets, which anyone in the now failing dinosaur of the commercial music industry will tell you is not the case.


English: montage of great classical music comp...
We forget that Classical Composers were once Contemporary Composers
It is not classical music that is failing. It is the ancient monolith who fails daily evidenced by the fall in traditional music industry models that ignore technology, ignore the economy, and ignore entire segments of the population with a sniff of the upturned nose as they rob artists, try to rob the public, and turn out little more but badly made copies of prior greatness.

I contend that we stop the wringing of our hands in both classical and commercial music. In a world where millions can just as easily pirate Lady Gaga or Beethoven, the issue is less of an artistic nature but whether those in charge of the greatest cultural and music institutions of our time are willing to conform and change to a new plugged-in, multicultural, multigenerational, multi-faceted online universe where the limits of musical creativity are unlimited.

We forget that Classical Composers were once Contemporary Composers.

I propose solutions which try to rectify the neglect of generations of children (now adults), neglect of lower to middle class income earners, neglect of classical music traditions outside of Europe, and neglect of today's burgeoning generations. Only by embracing technology and embracing our changing selves will classical music continue to survive the tests of time.

Award-winning contemporary composer Sabrina Pena Young's works have been performed throughout Asia, the Americas, Europe, and Australia. Young has been published in the Kapralova Society Journal, New Music Box, Percussive Notes, the SAI Music Journal, the SEAMUS Music Journal, and other arts websites and publications. Young is currently working on her modern opera, Libertaria: The Virtual Opera, which combines electronic music, machinima animation, and classical music in a riveting sci-fi opera set in post-USA New York in 2129AD.


Enhanced by Zemanta


The key to keeping classical music vibrant and alive is to embrace new technologies and capture a large audience via online resources. There are a number of composers who are already doing this such as Eric Whitacre and his piece for 2000 voices.

Popular posts from this blog

Top 10 Mistakes When Writing for Percussion

Top 10 Mistakes When Writing for Percussionby Sabrina Young
10. Indicating the wrong mallets for an instrument.Brass mallets on vibes? Try a hammer on a violin!

9. Writing the glockenspiel part as heard.You shouldn't have to climb a ladder of leger lines to read a glock part. Keep it in the staff.

8. When in doubt, adding more suspended cymbal.This is a huge mistake made by arrangers. Yep, cymbals add automatic intensity to a piece, but so can a bass drum roll, a rousing hand drum part, exciting mallet licks, or a hundred other combinations. Well-written percussion parts stand out in the band and church repertoire.

7. Better means more complicated, right?This is my main mistake. A percussion part can be simple enough for a middle school, but it is the ability to use the different tone colors of the percussion palette properly that indicates a maturity in writing, not that impossible part for the timpanist that has them playing timpani, gong, crash cymbals, and triangle in the span of…

Women in Multimedia and New Music bios, unedited

INSTRUCTIONS: Use your computers "FIND" feature to locate artist names in this document.

This is a short BIO list I made for my thesis "The Feminine Musique: Multimedia and Women Today" in 2005. It is a shortlist of bio info on composers and artists involved in interdisciplinary media work, with an emphasis on new music. References to specific web pages are given. The thesis can be checked out through interlibrary loan at Florida International University. I plan to post most of the information of my thesis online in time.

Rebecca Allen
Rebecca Allen (USA) is an internationally recognized media artist, inspired by the potential of advanced technology. Central to her work is the study of motion as a form of communication and creative expression. Allen has produced a number of commissioned works in Europe and the U.S. including computer animated films, interactive installations and large-scale multimedia performances. H…

The Real Composer Behind the Saturday Night Live What's Poppin Jazz Scat Video

Composer Janice Misurell-Mitchell is the Secret Inspiration Behind the SNL Skit Saturday Night Live lovers, who typically no longer watch Saturday Night Live on Saturday but
actually wait until Monday when it pops up on Hulu, enjoyed a rare hilarious bit from the "What's Poppin" skit, featuring a few, uhm, lets say non-traditional "hip hop" artists scatting away. Within a few minutes it's pretty clear that the performing musicians aren't what you would call mainstream hip hop artists, wearing strangely coordinated wardrobes and sporting a hip hop flute.

Watch the original Saturday Night Live Video.

Composer Janice Misurell-Mitchell is the inspiration behind this hilarious take on hip hop. 

You can watch the original version of Scat/Rap Counterpoint here, starring Misurell-Mitchell:

According to the composer:

"Scat/Rap Counterpoint presents various views of the dilemma in which American artists find themselves when they try to relate their work to their…